Case study № 2025-125 Ontario · Dividend portfolio · Ages 50–65

The return was perfect. The timing was worth $5,250.

Software files returns. We design them. One client, one RRSP receipt, two tax years — and a deduction that pays 5.5× more when it is split, not spent. Scroll through the actual working paper.

Two-year tax · as drafted$0
Two-year tax · re-timed$0
Recovered for the client$0
New lines of paperwork0
the working paper
01 The case file

A clean draft,
signed June 11

The 2025 T1 arrived from the preparer with a balance owing of $959.36 — technically flawless. But a draft return is a proposal, not a verdict. The interesting line is the one most people skim: 20800, the RRSP deduction.

T1 · 2025 · Income Tax and Benefit ReturnDraft
12000Dividends from the operating company (taxable amount)126,500.00
12100Interest & investment income21,006.42
13500Net self-employment income5,259.26
15000Total income152,765.68
20800RRSP deduction — as drafted−76,798.00
26000Taxable income75,279.98
48500Balance owing, 2025959.36
02 The mechanism

Dividend credits
don't carry forward

Canadian dividends arrive with built-in tax credits. Use them in the year they land — or lose them forever. The draft return deducts so much RRSP that the credits overshoot the tax they were meant to cancel.

In the 2025 draft, federal tax before credits is $11,989.90. The dividend tax credit plus personal credits supply $13,774.41 of relief.

The overshoot — credits with no tax left to absorb — simply evaporates. Meanwhile every RRSP dollar “spent” to create that overshoot was worth 48¢ next year, when $207,000 of grossed-up dividends will sit in Ontario's surtax band.

$0 of non-refundable credit destroyed in the 2025 draft — a quiet signal that the RRSP deduction is parked in the wrong year.
03 The instrument

One receipt,
two years — slide it

The CRA lets unused RRSP contributions carry forward indefinitely. So the $81,271.67 of total deductible room can be split between 2025 and 2026 in any proportion. Every split is a different total tax bill. This is the entire valley, computed live from the actual return.

Edit the case file change any T1 line or next year's income — the valley, optimum and filing instruction recompute live Open the editor
2025 · the T1 as drafted
2026 · the projection
Combined 2025 + 2026 tax  ·  by RRSP deducted on the 2025 return ▲ optimum   ● draft   ○ you
RRSP deducted in 2025 · line 20800 $76,798

Carry $4,473.67 forward and deduct it against 2026's $207,000 of grossed-up income.

2025 tax$959
2026 tax · projected$14,289
Federal Ontario CPP (self-emp.)
Two-year total $15,248
 

Why the valley floors at $59,017

Push the slider right of the optimum and each shifted dollar saves about 30¢ in 2025 but surrenders 48¢ in 2026 — Ontario surtax, the 29% federal bracket and the basic-personal-amount clawback all stack on those dividends. That's the cliff.

Push left and 2025 climbs into its own surtax faster than the 2026 dividend credits can give anything back — a gentle drift upward. The floor sits exactly where 2026's dividend credits are fully used and not a dollar wasted.

04 The verdict

Three ways to file
the same numbers

Identical income. Identical receipts. Identical software. The only variable is judgment about when — and it moves the two-year bill by 40%.

All-in 2025

Deduct $80,325 now $0 Two-year tax
2025$809
2026$15,991
vs optimal+$6,803

The draft

Deduct $76,798 · as prepared $0 Two-year tax
2025$959
2026$14,289
vs optimal+$5,250
Recommended

The split

$59,017 in 2025 · $22,255 in 2026 $0 Two-year tax
2025$4,741
2026$5,257
vs draft−$5,250

Same receipts. Same income. $5,250 apart.

05 The method

How we read
a draft

Every Capital Assist review runs the same discipline — software for the arithmetic, a human for the strategy, and a model for everything the forms won't tell you.

  1. Rebuild the return from slips — our model reproduced this draft to the penny ($959.36) before we touched a single assumption.
  2. Project the next twenty-four months — dividends planned, room accruing, brackets indexing, credits expiring.
  3. Sweep every legal allocation — all 80,325 possible RRSP splits were costed; the valley above is the complete answer, not a rule of thumb.
  4. File the cheapest true return — and document why, so the recommendation survives a CRA question.

Assumptions & limitations. 2025 figures are taken from the draft T1 (file RC-25-103) prepared by Capital Assist Professional Corporation, June 11 2026: Ontario resident, non-eligible dividends of $126,500 (taxable amount), interest $21,006.42, net self-employment $5,259.26, RRSP deduction limit $80,325. The 2026 projection assumes $150,000 of eligible dividends (grossed-up $207,000) and no other income; 2025 brackets and amounts indexed ≈2%; lowest federal rate 14%; eligible dividend credits at 15.0198% federal / 10% Ontario of the taxable amount; Ontario health premium per the published table. Alternative minimum tax was tested and does not apply in either year (adjusted taxable income remains under the AMT exemption). CPP on self-employment earnings ($209.36) is invariant to the allocation.

This page is an illustration of planning methodology, not tax advice. Outcomes depend on facts, law and rates in force at filing. Figures will be re-verified against the client's Notice of Assessment and 2026 slips before any amendment is filed.